TL;DR
- ✓Many private PPO plans ask health questions before you can join.
- ✓Your answers decide which plans you can choose. There is usually no second round.
- ✓Many questions look back 24 months or 5 years, and a pending test or surgery can count.
- ✓Apply while you feel good and nothing is pending, so every door stays open.
- ✓Always answer honestly. A plan can cancel coverage if something was left off.
Many private health plans decide who can join based on a short set of health questions. When you apply while you are healthy, with no tests or procedures pending, you are far more likely to qualify for the plans with the best networks and value. Wait until something changes, and some of those doors may close.
Last week I talked about timing your 2027 plan review. This week, here is why timing matters so much for the self employed, 1099 pros, and small business owners.
Two kinds of health plans, two sets of rules
Marketplace plans (the ones you find on HealthCare.gov or your state exchange) follow the Affordable Care Act. They cannot turn you down or charge you more because of a preexisting condition. That is a wonderful protection. The tradeoff is that you can usually only sign up during open enrollment, which runs November 1 through January 15 in most states, unless you have a qualifying life event. (HealthCare.gov)
Many of the private PPO plans I love work differently. They are often built for working owners and independent contractors, they can start on the first of almost any month, and they often come with national networks your doctors already know. But they are medically underwritten. That means before you can join, you answer a set of health questions.
How the health questions work
Here is what surprises most people. On the plans I work with, the health questions are the whole decision. One carrier's guide puts it plainly: whatever options show up after you finish the health questions are the options you have. There is no further review.
The questions usually ask about things like:
- ✓Hospital stays in the past 24 months (an ER visit alone usually does not count)
- ✓Serious conditions like cancer or heart disease in the past 5 years
- ✓Specialty or injectable medications you take now
- ✓Tests, results, or surgeries that are recommended but not yet done
- ✓Seeing several specialists for an ongoing condition
A "yes" on certain questions can mean the plans with full coverage disappear from your screen. What is left are simpler plans that anyone can get, which often have tighter limits.
And here is the good news: on some plans, everyday conditions like high blood pressure, high cholesterol, thyroid issues, or asthma do not automatically knock you out. Every carrier is different, which is exactly why it helps to have a strategist look at the questions with you.
Why "while you are healthy" matters so much
Life changes fast. A doctor recommends an MRI. A knee starts acting up and surgery is "probably next year." You start a new medication. But on an underwritten plan, any one of them can change your answers, and your answers change your options.
When you apply while you feel good and nothing is pending, you keep every door open. That is the heart of what I mean when I say feeling good is your secret weapon.
Honesty protects you
Please hear me on this one: always answer every question truthfully. Carriers can check your medical and prescription history when you file a claim. If something was left off, they can deny the claim, cancel your coverage, and simply refund your premium. That is the worst possible time to find out you are not covered.
What I do on our call
In about 30 minutes, we will walk through the health questions together, privately and calmly, check that your doctors and prescriptions are covered, and compare private and Marketplace options side by side for 2027.
And if what you have is already the right fit, I will tell you. I am here to educate you, not to sell you.
Book your 2027 plan review
If you are self employed or run a small business and you are feeling good right now, this is your moment. Let us look at your options before anything changes.
Frequently asked questions
Can a private plan turn me down because of my health?
Yes. Many private plans are medically underwritten, so your answers to health questions decide which plans you can choose. Marketplace plans cannot turn you down or charge you more for a preexisting condition.
What happens if I leave something off my application?
Do not do it. Carriers can check your history when you file a claim. If they find something was left off, they can deny the claim and cancel your coverage.
When is the best time to apply?
When you are healthy and nothing is pending, like a test result or a planned surgery. Private plans can often start on the first of a month, so you do not always have to wait for open enrollment.
This is a solicitation for insurance. Plan availability and eligibility vary by state and applicant. Christine Kieffer, Licensed Health Insurance Strategist, NPN #19652136.
Get Christine's Insights Every Wednesday
One short email a week with the newest article on health coverage, taxes and benefits for 1099 pros, families and small business owners. Unsubscribe anytime.